The One Jewish State Solution

One Jewish State Solution
Gilad Atzmon writes:

Some of the more advanced Israel/Palestine commentators have agreed among themselves that the “one-state solution” amounts to empty talk for the simple reason that Palestine is “one-state” already: It has natural borders, one electric grid and even one international pre-dial number (+972). But this beautiful and historic land, stretched from the river to the sea, is dominated by a foreign and hostile ideology that is racially supremacist and vile towards the indigenous people of the land.

Some of those perceptive analysts have been bewildered following a peculiar shift in Israeli politics: while the so-called Israeli “left” has been advocating racial and ethnic segregation between Jews and Palestinians by adopting the two-state solution, it is actually the Zionist ultra-right that has been pushing constantly for an integration of the “land” by means of Israeli annexation.

Two weeks ago, a Haaretz poll revealed that 42 per cent of Israelis back West Bank annexation. Apparently, 16 per cent of those polled support annexing the entire West Bank without giving any political rights to the Palestinians who live there.

While very few within the Israeli left joined the call for a one-state solution, it seems as if Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and the entire Israeli right are thrilled by the idea.

Netanyahu vowed on April 6 to extend Israeli sovereignty to the settlements of the West Bank if he is re-elected in the April 9 poll.

Netanyahu’s declaration shouldn’t take us by surprise. Two weeks ago, a Haaretz poll revealed that 42 per cent of Israelis back West Bank annexation. Apparently, 16 per cent of those polled support annexing the entire West Bank without giving any political rights to the Palestinians who live there. I guess that it is hard not to see the political reasoning behind Netanyahu’s promise to annex settlements. Netanyahu, who is likely to form the next Israeli government, is attempting to appeal to the Israeli ultra-right voters. He wants them to vote Likud on April 9 rather than “wasting” their vote on a small ultra-right party or another.

There is obviously a big difference between the one-state call that has been pushed by Palestinian solidarity activists and Netanyahu’s politics of annexation. While Palestinian rights advocates are referring to one democratic state, Netanyahu is not committed to democracy at all. He is solely faithful to the Jewish population and what he offers in practice is a “One Jewish State Solution”. After all, Israel defines itself as “the Jewish State” and it is there to serve one people while denying others their most elementary rights. 

Israel, as we know, is not a state of its citizens; it is a state of its Jewish citizens. By the time Israel comes to term with its sin and transcends into a state of its citizens regardless of their race, ethnicity or religious belief, it will be renamed. It may as well be called Palestine.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Tiny URL for this post: